Saturday, December 6, 2008

From Crisis to Sustainability

This article appeared in TODAY Weekend, Dec 6-7 2008

The fight for climate change has lost its impetus, but the planet’s needs are no less pressing now

A YEAR is a long time in global politics.

Late last year, global warming was, pardon the pun, the hot topic. Mr Al Gore and the International Panel on Climate Change won the Nobel Peace prize. The world’s ministers met in Bali and agreed on a two-year road map to negotiate new commitments to curb climate change.

Half that time has gone. Ministers began their meetings this week in Poznan, Poland. Yet while the meeting is on schedule, there is something of an impasse and, worse, a lack of urgency. The world’s attention has shifted to issues that seem more pressing than climate change. The global financial crisis and looming recession threaten economies and jobs. Terrible events in Mumbai remind us that terrorism is by no means solved or confined to fringe, faraway places.

Another factor is the fall in oil prices. Not so long ago, oil was past US$120 per barrel and predictions were that it would reach US$200. This expectation combined with predictions of climate change catastrophe to fuel interest in alternative energy that would not just be affordable, but also less carbon-intensive.

Now, with oil prices down and credit dried up, some high-profile projects in wind turbines and other alternative energies have slowed or stopped.

A third factor has been the United States’ position of staying out of the Kyoto Protocol. So long as President George W Bush says no, there is little reason for developing countries like China, India and Indonesia to accept binding obligations to cap their growing emissions.

The world has been held to a kind of prisoner’s dilemma among these large emitters, pointing fingers to blame each other. It is a sad game, with no one taking a long-term view of the global common good.

Poznan is unlikely to achieve much. Yet Asians would be wrong to ignore climate change.

Why climate change matters First, combating climate change is not a luxury. It threatens the fundamentals of human existence. Along with the economy and the wars, it’s the third crisis we face, just one of a different nature.

When a hurricane hits, as Katrina did in New Orleans, people recognise the kind of consequences that unchecked climate change can bring. But otherwise, effects like rising sea levels are harder to see. Yet by the time the impact is felt, it may well be too late to find a solution. To deal with climate change, we need to recognise the difference between the urgent and the important.

Secondly, expect oil prices in the middle- to longterm to steady and then rise. The present low prices are like a balloon that has been deflated. Once the hype of the US$200 barrel gave way, speculators exited their positions, sending prices sharply down. Energy use may not grow much in the next year with the recession and lower industrial demand.

Looking ahead, however, fundamentals remain to drive prices back up from the present. The long-term predictions still point to diminishing oil reserves, while energy demand will rise, especially from Asia.

Third, and perhaps most importantly, expect America to change its position on climate change. President-elect Barack Obama campaigned with detailed plans on the issue. He is, moreover, not alone.

While Mr Bush was in denial, many leading American companies, cities and states have been pushing for ways to deal with climate change. Once Mr Obama is in office, there will be a new impetus for change in the US.

One major effort will likely be tied to America’s economic stimulus package against the recession. Some anticipate that the Obama administration will use some of the funds to boost investments in green infrastructure. This would spur America’s middle- to long-term recovery and transformation to a carbon-lite economy.

As the US takes its own steps forward, they will need other countries to come on board, especially those with large emissions. A Bill introduced in the US Senate already threatens to impose heavy taxes on imports from countries that do not have a price for carbon, like China and India.

It will be a loss if the green cause is used to cover up bully-boy tactics and protectionism. The better outcome would be a global system to foster the exchange of technology and provide funds to effectively help developing countries cut emissions without killing off their economies.

What’s in it for Asia? How should Asians respond? At present, India is on record that it will not act, since its emissions per capita are so much lower than America’s. China has taken on national energy efficiency plans, but refused any international obligations.

They would be right to reject any plan to deal with climate change that fails to equitably recognise their need for development. They are also right to be wary of American pressure and protectionism. But there are, nevertheless, reasons for Asians to act.

Some countries and cities in Asia are extremely vulnerable to the effects of climate change. Many also are concerned with energy security in the long run, as oil reserves dwindle.

If they properly recognise these twin vulnerabilities, Asians can and should invest in avoiding climate change and embrace alternatives that can power their economies forward without more carbon. They, too, should invest in a carbon-light economy and infrastructure for the future.

Asians can change the game for themselves, and in tandem with America under Mr Obama. The world can and needs to move from crisis to sustainability. If not at Poznan, then soon.

Monday, December 1, 2008

Feeling the Chill in China

This column appeared in TODAY Weekend, Dec 1-2 2008

THERE are reasons not to go to China in winter. The cold is bitter, especially in the North this year. Almost everyone comes back with the flu or cough. Concerns about food safety leave you wondering what is safe to eat and what isn’t.

Yet the plane from safe, warm Singapore to Beijing is full.

One Singaporean I met was on the way to meet mainland officials in charge of food and drug safety. Another, running a household Singaporean name in Chinese medicine, was visiting the Traditional Chinese Medicine academy in Beijing. A third, well known former civil servant Ngiam Tong Dow, was travelling to speak at a Chinese entrepreneurship conference.

The plane is full not because people love to visit China. It’s full because China is full of opportunity and need. For years, the Chinese economy has been the hottest source of growth and dynamism, pulling along many others to form a regional production platform with exports to the markets of America and Europe.

As recession hits the developed economies in the United States, Europe and Japan, some hope that China can do something to offset the expected downturn.

Yet, just as temperatures are dropping sharply, could the hot Chinese economy be getting cold? And, with the storms in global financial markets, could this be more than a seasonal downturn?

Projections are that China will still grow at about 8 per cent in the coming year. This is considerable, compared to developed markets which are expected to face slow or no growth. But China is not unaffected.

Some factories are closing, notably in the Pearl River Delta where costs have risen, and among uncompetitive state-owned enterprises. Industrial output has slowed to a crawl, the lowest in seven years. Real estate prices are softening in many cities. Lower Chinese demand for energy and resources have driven down commodity prices worldwide.

A slowdown in China was already anticipated after the summer Olympics and with the unfolding crisis, China’s economy is feeling the effects.

AT THE HEART OF THE MATTER

I felt this viscerally when I visited the town of Langfang, a 90-minute drive out from Beijing. The town has a light industrial park, a university and a growing new town for residents. An American electronics manufacturer occupies a huge block in Phase 1 of the industrial park, complete with housing for the workers.

There were ambitious plans to grow. But demand in America and the electronics sector has slumped and expansion has slowed. Beyond phase 1, some structures remain incomplete, and although more land has been cleared, some stands empty.

On the Sunday I visited, workers were out strolling. The area is one of the poorer provinces and is thus a source for low-cost labour for major cities. The industrial park is just one of the many projects that have to succeed here and across China if there are to be enough jobs.

That’s one reason why Chinese leaders rolled out a stimulus package worth nearly US$600 billion ($917 billion). The Chinese will spend on infrastructure, and not bail out companies, in the name of protecting jobs. But a lot of the motivation is to keep up growth, provide jobs and avoid unrest.

Recent weeks have seen a number of protests in China by taxi drivers, workers and assorted crowds. Protests pop up now and again in different parts of the country, but bear particular attention in this period of downturn.

I SCRATCH YOUR BACK ...

Long before this crisis, Chinese thinkers emphasised how the country needs a benevolent international environment to allow it to focus on domestic development and deal with issues like jobs and inequality.

External economic conditions have grown harsher than winter and China will be tested by these tough times. China needs to keep growing for both economic and political reasons.

The world can gain from China’s continued growth. An economically healthy China can continue to hold US Treasury Bills, contributing in this way to financing stability abroad. A growing China will continue to have needs and will therefore offer opportunities to all who come with a marketable product. Many multinationals, for example, can anticipate participating in building infrastructure in China with the stimulus package.

Some hope that China can and will do more. A few troubled countries have already come to Beijing, hoping for bilateral assistance. Others want China to contribute more to the multilateral financial agencies, like the World Bank.

Chinese leaders have responded by saying that their best contribution is to keep growing. Investing to build up its own infrastructure seems a sound investment of the country’s considerable reserves.

To keep its own economy growing may sound selfish to some. But I read it as a realistic admission that while China is a rising power, it is not yet there, and it is not vouchsafed against turbulence.

Imagine the opposite scenario: A China that is overstretched abroad and troubled at home, economically stagnant and with restive citizens causing instability. Sometimes helping others begins at home.