Showing posts with label human rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label human rights. Show all posts

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Does Asia’s silence mean consent?


THE Iranian election results have been met by angry protests in some quarters and silence in others. Angry voices swell among Iranians in the country and abroad who question the election results that returned incumbent President, Mr Mahmoud Ahmadinejad by a landslide.

They lead a worldwide, Internet-savvy campaign asking: “Where is my vote?” European governments, including those of the United Kingdom and Germany, have taken the moral high ground, strongly calling for accountability and verification of the result.

In contrast, the United States and Asia have been quiet and careful. There is probably some preference in Washington, DC for Mr Mir-Hossein Mousavi, touted as a reformist. But President Barack Obama’s administration has to engage Iran if it is to prevent the country pursuing a path towards nuclear weapons. Another geopolitical consideration is that Iran is important for the US in dealing with Afghanistan and Pakistan.

So no matter who the winner is, the US needs to deal with the Iranian government, and must be pragmatic.

For Asia’s emerging powers, geopolitical reasons dictate silence, ambivalence or support for the results.

China’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang voiced respect for “the choice of the Iranian people” and called for stability after the elections. China has considerable interest in Iran’s energy resources. While differences with the US over Iran have been minimised in recent years, Beijing has carefully avoided joining in the reprimanding or imposition of sanctions.

For India, ties with Iran have strategic implications for the Afghanistan-Pakistan issue. There are also hopes for a oil pipeline that will stretch from Iran to India, through Pakistan, which would help meet Indian energy needs. India is the world’s most populous democracy, but it has generally not been an active advocate for democracy abroad.

Another big Asian democracy has also supported the results in Iran. Indonesia is reported to say it “congratulates the people of Iran for exercising their vote with a high turnout, and a peaceful and orderly process. We respect the election result from the voting of the Iranian people that re-elected President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad”.

This may disappoint some who have seen Indonesia’s democracy develop over the last decade and deliver credible results, including in the most recent Parliamentary elections. Indonesia has taken steps to reduce voter fraud, corruption and used “quick count” methods to reduce electoral irregularities and uncertainties despite a populous and dispersed archipelago. Indonesia also invited external monitors into the country for earlier elections; Iran did not.

But Indonesia’s position shows up how economic interests outweigh democratic ideology. Trade between the two Muslim countries has been growing, especially in the energy sector, and by last year was more than US$500 million ($727 million). When Indonesia served on the United Nations Security Council in 2007, it often wavered over complaints about Iran’s nuclear programme. Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudoyhono has even supported Iran’s right to peacefully develop nuclear energy.

Other Asian countries have yet to make their positions known. Some have reacted to protests, like in Malaysia, where police were reported to have used tear gas to break up a noisy protest against the result by Iranians in Kuala Lumpur.

But it seems unlikely that Asians will take as strong a stance as Europeans have. If the larger Asian powers have geopolitical and economic interests at stake, others have quite the opposite reason - they lack sufficient interest in Iran.

Many governments may plead that it is difficult to know if the results are indeed rigged since Iran did not allow independent international monitoring. It is true that allegations of irregularity are based on conjecture and hypothesis. That, for example, it is incredulous that official results show Mr Moussavi losing even in his home state and among those who share his ethnicity. But the lack of hard evidence lends a fig leaf for silence.

What I hope Asian silence does not mean is that no one much cares about the veracity of elections. The region will face a series of upcoming elections, in countries where polls have sometimes been less than free and fair.

The Indonesian presidential elections will be held in the coming months. Talk is that elections in Thailand may be called before the year is up. Next year, we can expect elections in the Philippines for a new President. Even in Myanmar, the regime has promised polls next year in line with its road map to democracy.

In Asia, protests have often followed elections and sometimes - as with the Philippines and Thailand - these have led to a change of leaders. We must therefore hope that some meaning of “free and fair elections” can be agreed, and measures put in place to verify results.

Democracy is now the key legitimising factor for governments in Asia and across the world, and elections are its foundation stone. Silence over the Iranian elections may be seem necessary because of larger strategic concerns over nuclear proliferation. Silence may be excused if there is no clearer evidence that results were rigged.

But the lesson cannot be that Asians will keep silent because a country can promise energy resources and economic deals, or has strategic importance. Countries like Myanmar can otherwise claim licence to do what they want. Only weak and unimportant countries would be held accountable.

If those are the lessons Asians draw from the Iranian elections, it will not be only Iranians who suffer. So will Asian democracy.

Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Human Rights: ASEAN’s Way Forward

THE Asean Charter, unveiled at last year’s Singapore Summit, surprised many by giving attention to human rights, enshrining these as a purpose and principle.

Article 14 of the Charter promises to create a human rights body for the group. Many welcomed this as a bold step, and even much-criticised Myanmar signed off on the Charter.

Another step forward will soon be taken. Next month, a high-level panel will be set up to agree on terms of reference for the new body.

But, despite the move towards democracy in some Asean countries, others doubt the region as a whole is ready to move ahead with human rights. And, as a recent workshop in Singapore for experts, non-governmental organisations and officials revealed, differences remain.

A first point of division is whether the Asean human rights body should comprise governmental officials or independent experts. If experts are appointed, they would have the independence to be more critical of violations. In contrast, government officials may play it safer rather than jeopardise friendly relations.

A second difference of opinion is whether it should have powers to investigate complaints in countries, like a regional police. Others propose that it only promote and monitor human rights.

A third controversy is whether all member countries should be on board, or if a minority who are willing may proceed more quickly.

Yet, while there are intra-Asean differences, there are areas of agreement that hold out the possibility of moving ahead together.

There are good reasons to do so. Consensus is the basic principle for the group. While the Charter does allow for an “Asean minus X” formula, this is expressly limited to economic agreements.

Maintaining Asean unity is key, especially on high-profile issues like human rights.

Yet, louder democracies in Asean, like Indonesia and the Philippines, may not wish to move only at the pace of the more cautious countries. Creative thinking is needed to find ways so that a foundation can be agreed for all, while allowing some to go further and faster.

Optional protocol agreements are one established method used by the international community for such purposes. This could be applied to differences of opinion about the powers for the Asean human rights body.

While the Asean Charter promises both promotion and protection for human rights, a variety of tools can be used. The international community already deploys a mixed tool kit, ranging from court-like proceedings and investigations by an international criminal court, to the use of force to prevent genocide and crimes against humanity.

But softer methods are also used, like monitoring, where a state reports on its human rights record, and opens itself to comments by others. Even today, the main method is still to “name and shame”.

Asean might proceed similarly with promotion and monitoring for all states, while some, using an optional protocol, could open themselves up to investigation if there are complaints.

The composition of the human rights body could also be balanced. Rather than one or the other, there could be a politically appointed panel of high officials, as well as an additional committee of experts.

Asean can also build a strong but limited foundation that all can agree on.

This is possible for women’s and children’s rights. All Asean countries have agreed to the relevant international treaties, albeit with some reservations.

Asean has also issued a strong declaration on the need to protect the rights of migrant workers. As Asean economies have become closely integrated, the movement of people across borders has grown. Moving ahead with transboundary issues that face migrants and women, like trafficking of women for sexual purposes, could help hundreds of thousands.

In comparison, to focus on individual cases that are within the domestic politics of any country can be of limited value and invoke many sensitivities.

The High-Level Panel to be established will have much important work to do. It should consult stakeholders broadly so that the process is perceived to be open and inclusive.

Human rights are no longer an alien concept, in contrast to the talk about “Asian values” so prevalent in the ’90s. Asean should set out a long-term vision for a regional human rights body of the highest standard.

But the roadmap to that vision may need to be travelled step-by-step so that all countries join in that journey. Asean should avoid the situation that some race ahead while others — perhaps Vietnam, Laos and Myanmar — stand still. Only if Asean proceeds with some fundamental baselines can human rights help unify the promised regional community.

Monday, August 6, 2007

Real Steps, Not Rhetoric

By Simon SC Tay, TODAY, August 6 2007

ASEAN Foreign Ministers in Manila this week surprised many by agreeing on a human rights commission, after initially strong objections by Myanmar.

While this will delight human rights supporters, the Association of South-east Asian Nations may yet frustrate hopes and expectations. For while there is agreement to put a mechanism for human rights into the charter being drafted for the grouping, there is no consensus on the commission’s scope, how it will operate or even when it will start.

Hopes will run high, especially among those non-governmental organisations that have been pushing for an Asean human rights mechanism — Asean governments had raised the possibility of creating one back in 1993.

Cynics may, however, suggest that Asean’s current move is more about perception. It is likely that habits of consultationwill continue, and states remain cautious about clashing over matters solely within another’s sovereign territory.

What can be expected? How can Asean move forward, avoiding cynicism on one hand and over-ambition on the other?

The context for this new initiative is important. The grouping aims to be a community with economic, security and sociocultural pillars by 2015. To be a community, mutual understanding needs to be fostered, including on the rights of individuals — not just between governments, but also the peoples of the region. While there are universal norms of human rights, differences in the levels of economic development, religion and other characteristics can make understanding and practices vary from one society to another.

Secondly, human rights commissions and mechanisms do differ from each other. Europe has the most advanced mechanism. Citizens from one country are allowed to complain and bring cases against any country before a regional court on the full gamut of human rights.

The decisions of that regional court can override the national courts and change national laws and practices. This process that allows individuals to complain is a legal revolution in rights for Europeans emerging in parallel with the creation of a European Union.

Without a similar commitment to a political union in the immediate future, Asean cannot realistically emulate Europe. It would be like comparing apples to durians.

Asean should understand the European experience without idolising or aping it. After all, other regional human rights mechanisms exist in the Americas and Africa but work in more limited ways. In many cases, rather than emphasising court-like procedures, the systems give ample room for political negotiation and compromise.

Human rights mechanisms grow over time. At the United Nations, for example, the past decade has seen such mechanisms strengthened with the creation of a human rights commissioner and the revamp of its council. Separate tribunals have also been set up to handle specific situations such as the former Yugoslavia. While far from perfect, these have been improvements.

Asean may, similarly, begin its human rights initiative more modestly, while holding out the possibility of stronger mechanisms in the future. Where can Asean best begin?

Public education is a necessary foundation. In rural districts in some Asean member states, the understanding of human rights may be rudimentary or even non-existent. In some Asean capitals too, human rights continue to be controversial and seen as an alien, “Western” concept. Sentiments still echo from the 1990s, when spokesmen from Singapore, Malaysia and other states spoke about “Asian values” that differed from the West.

Public education on human rights in Asean can, and should, reframe that debate. Asean’s peoples need to understand human rights and see them as being part of their own heritage and beliefs, rather than a Western imposition.

But what about taking action? A key challenge is deciding where to begin. Some will point to the problems in Myanmar. Others may emphasise issues of media freedom or the need to protect racial and religious minorities.

Perhaps one way to prioritise is to look at existing areas of agreement among Asean member states. While there are many international human rights treaties and conventions, only two have near-universal acceptance in the region.

These two conventions are on the rights of children and the elimination of discrimination against women. Asean can usefully begin by targeting the illegal traffic in women and children. More broadly, improving the rights of Asean children to education, shelter and food can help ensure the basic rights or the region’s future generation.

Another priority would seem to be where the human rights issue is not wholly within one country but has a transboundary element. Foreign workers are an example. The large flows of workers between Asean member states is likely to increase as we move towards closer economic integration.

Yet, tensions over their treatment surface regularly. In Malaysia, for example, thousands of undocumented Indonesian workers are being held by the authorities. Intra-Asean cooperation can help ensure the fair treatment of foreign workers. Frictions and fears about working abroad can be eased, and this would help economic integration.

What, then, will Asean do about human rights in Myanmar? Political sensitivities and security dimensions still exist. Ties with China, India and other major powers must also enter into the equation for any solution.

Pressing for change by Asean is needed but that is best left to political judgement by leaders and foreign ministers.

An Asean human rights commission may, however, assist by providing timely information and assessment on the human rights situation in that country.

In keeping with so much in Asean, the key to moving ahead with a human rights mechanism is to take first steps in a timely manner. But it is also important that the steps be real ones, not rhetoric or empty promises. It would also help if the steps were to be aligned with the overall ambitions of being a community. The journey ahead will be long but Asean is heading in the right direction.