Showing posts with label obama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label obama. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Dear Mr Obama, Don't Forget Asia

ANTICIPATION grows as Mr Barack Obama’s inauguration as United States President on Jan 20 approaches.

Across the country, and indeed the world, his message of change esonates even as an exhausted Bush administration exits from office amid a global economic crisis and American entanglement in two wars.

But what about the new administration’s engagement with Asia? Asia has not featured strongly on the campaign trail or in the run-up to the inauguration. Yet, Asia represents a new and necessary dimension in America’s foreign engagements.

Even as President Obama and his team begin their work, they must understand that in the eight years the Democrats have been out of the Oval Office, Asia has grown immeasurably.

The region’s growth is not just in economic terms. Asians have a growing confidence to deal with their own issues and contribute to global governance.

Mr Obama has talked about being more multilateral and must recognise that the global community now has more stakeholders than the established powers of Europe and Japan. New forms of global governance and new ways of engaging rising Asian powers will be critical for success.

Asia policy can no longer be a tidy box of simple, bilateral relationships. There is a need to see broader implications for the region and on global regimes. A central challenge will be to link Asia policy with priority global issues.

Take ties with China, for example. These have matured, despite differences over issues like Tibet and the buildup of the Chinese armed forces. On other fronts including North Korea and the cross-straits issues, the two countries have learnt to manage their co-existence and shown the ability to cooperate pragmatically.

Next steps will be to engage China in stabilising the global financial system and helping the global economy recover. There is also great opportunity for the two countries to share lessons on dealing with climate change.

India’s case is similar. Many in India acclaim President George W Bush as the first American President to recognise India’s stature. His initiative to go outside the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) to recognize India a nuclear power is celebrated. But this can be a mixed blessing.

There is concern the NPT has been sacrificed in the process. Now, states like North Korea and Iran have more room to say that they too, like India, should be exceptions to the nuclear club rules.

The close US-India relationship will also need to be adroitly triangulated with relations with an unstable and prickly Pakistan, and the new Afghanistan initiative Mr Obama has promised.

Can this be done? Much depends on the ability of the new administration to coordinate policies beyond the “stove pipes” of narrow compartmentalisation between what are global issues as opposed to issues limited to particular Asian countries.

The new Asia team will also need to capture the attention of the President at critical junctures to understand Asian perspectives, even as he grapples with pressing domestic and global priorities.

At present, the Obama team on Asia centres on two key names: Mr Jeff Bader, who will be National Security Council Senior Director for Asia, and Mr Kurt Campbell is State Department Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific affairs. Both are experienced former officials, presently with think-tanks.

Old hands in Asia


Mr Bader is said to be the key Obama adviser on Asia, and knows China very well, having led negotiations on China’s accession to the World Trade Organization. Early on, he was a political officer in Beijing and worked on the response to the Tiananmen Square incident. Mr Bader later became the State Department China director, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific affairs and director of Asian affairs at the National Security Council.

After some 27 years in administration, he left to head the Thornton Centre on China at the Brookings Institution think-tank.

Mr Kurt Campbell, although younger, has also served in several capacities in government. Best known among these was his stint as the Pentagon’s Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defence for Asia and the Pacific during the Clinton administration.

After leaving government, he was with well-known think-tank the Centre for Strategic and International Studies in Washington DC, before co-founding the Centre for New American Security.

Both are well regarded by other USbased experts for their intellect and experience on Asian issues. Mr Bader is said to be “extremely talented”, pragmatic and open-minded, which could assist him in new thinking about Asia. And there is hope Mr Campbell can help coordinate Asia policy between State and the Pentagon.

A third and prominent name that may feature could be Mr Richard Holbrooke. Tough, sharp-minded and outspoken, he was President Bill Clinton’s Ambassador to the United Nations, and it was he who hammered out the Dayton Peace Accords. The media is speculating that Mr Holbrooke may serve as special adviser on Pakistan and Afghanistan.

This is an especially tricky assignment, critical to both the American interests and the wider South Asia. Mr Holbrooke, currently chairman of the Asia Society, has been deeply engaged on Afghanistan in these past years, and was highly critical of the Bush administration’s inattention to this “forgotten war”.

Relationships depend not only on having a new or the right policies. Success, or failure, often rides on the people driving the policies. Mr Obama’s choices for key officeholders has, on the whole, added to the sense of optimism. The reputation of the team selected for Asia adds to that. But a difficult agenda lies ahead for the new President, and even the best and the brightest will be challenged.

Saturday, November 1, 2008

What Kind of President Will He Be?

This article appeared in TODAY Weekend Nov 1-2 2008

High hopes but a hard start for an Obama presidency

THERE is a great need for leadership in our turbulent world. Many hope that the new American President can help provide it.

If Mr Barack Obama wins the presidency, as polls now predict, he will ride on a wave of optimism and hope. This is generated by his message of change, his personal charisma and the history-making symbolism of an African-American in the White House.

Yet, that high wave of hope may hit a wall and leave Mr Obama’s presidency and the country wallowing in choppy waters. There are difficult and quite immediate problems ahead that promise a hard start.

The well-known American diplomat Richard Holbrooke, writing in Foreign Affairs, says that the President will face a more difficult opening day set of problems than any predecessor has faced since at least the end of World War II. This estimate was given even before the financial turmoil.

A recession is upon the United States. Candidate Obama gained momentum by promising to bring back growth and protect American jobs. But most predict a downturn for one or two years, and President Obama will struggle to deliver on those promises, perhaps even by mid-term. Problems may deepen and patience among citizens will be in short supply.

President Obama will need to restore confidence to the US and must put an economic team of the highest credibility into place, quickly. To help re-energise the world economy, a major step would be for freer trade, reviving the stalled Doha round and the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec), which Singapore will chair next year.

Yet, critics say that he and the Democrats, who dominate Congress, are protectionists who will isolate America and end up hurting the world economy. President Obama must be persuaded that America’s economy is inextricably linked to the world. He will need to show political courage and skill to pursue growth and trade, while keeping his support base on side.

A connected challenge will be climate change and energy. Even as President George W Bush was in denial, the public, companies and many states clamoured for America to respond to the existential threat of climate change. Both candidates promise steps forward, but Mr Obama has the more detailed plan to introduce permits to limit the amount of carbon that companies can emit.

Expectations both nationally and internationally are that President Obama will bring the US on board the Kyoto Protocol and join in global efforts to stem climate change. Can he live up to expectation, during an economic downturn?

Cynics say climate change action should be postponed as oil and gas are now cheaper, and introducing carbon permits will add costs that companies can’t afford.

Others retort that investing in new technologies and low carbon infrastructure can help pump up investment and help not just the environment, but also lower the American thirst for oil and increase their competitiveness.

Security will be a prime challenge. The US faces military overstretch with the quagmires in Iraq and Afghanistan, and yet the fear of another terrorist strike still nags.

Senator Obama opposed the war on Iraq from the start. On the campaign trail, candidate Obama said that military victory in Iraq, as Mr Bush is pushing for, is not possible and declared he would withdraw troops from open ended commitments. Yet, President Obama will find that timing will be critical.

In both Iraq and Afghanistan, he will need to ensure that new political structures achieve some stability, both internally and with neighbours. Diplomacy, rather than military might, will now be the key. For this, a major rethink is needed for US policy not only with these two countries, but in dealing with allies Turkey and Pakistan, and opening dialogue with Iran, with whom Mr Bush seemed close to waging war.

In a wider context, Middle East policy will need to be addressed. Since about 2003, this has been more of a “Muddle” East policy with little coordination, and no concept beyond the all-encompassing “global war on terror”.

Relations with the rest of the world will benefit immeasurably if President Obama can begin in earnest with these difficult and pressing problems and show even modest progress.

If President Obama shows he is more multilateral and communicative, and interested in more than just global terrorism, he can be prove as inspiring in Asia and globally, as he has among many American people, and offer leadership to a turbulent world.

US ties with Asia will follow in track. Relative to other regions, there are not too many immediate problems, although there have been absences and a badgering, unilateral tone that have hurt.

Relationships across the Pacific instead bring great opportunities and medium term challenges in dealing with issues like restoring economic growth, climate change, and a possible jostle for influence and leadership among rising Asian powers.

If President Obama gets it right, the US can be part of this region, as it has since the end of WWII and fully participate in its rise, as a leader in a multipolar world.

But if there is no patience among Americans for economic recovery and domestic forces try to protect jobs by closing off America, the Obama presidency may flounder.

He and America will then miss opportunities not only in Asia, but in re-establishing American leadership just when the world needs leadership. The first months and year will bear close watching.