Saturday, August 2, 2008

The End of Cheap and Good

TODAY Weekend • August 2, 2008

INFLATION figures in Singapore have hit record highs, with over 6 per cent reported for the first months, the highest for 25 years, and then holding at 7.5 per cent from April to June. This has surprised many Singaporeans, who wonder why it has happened and what to do about it.

To some, it is a kind of opportunity. In May, I was in California with old friends who had emigrated and they told me how so many Singaporeans come to visit just to go shopping. Everything seems so cheap there, especially with the decline of the United States dollar.

For many others, inflation has been a sudden and strong shock after years of strong growth and low inflation. In contrast, this year’s growth target is for a modest 4 to 6 per cent, with an inflation target of 6 to 7 per cent offsetting much of it.

Some say this is inevitable because of a global surge in inflation combined with uncertainties in the US market. This is certainly part of the picture.

But to me, the situation shows more. It portends the collision between a long-standing myth about the country and the vision for our future.

The myth is that things in Singapore should be “cheap and good”. And for a long time, they were. Real wages grew for decades, doubling between 1990 and 2000, and inflation was contained. Even big ticket items like housing and cars actually came down from the late ‘90s until about 2006. Now, however, many more are facing spiralling costs of basic goods from oil to rice, as well as the bite of GST on everything.

Being Singaporean, we’ll still rush and queue up at the great sales. But this may be simply to avoid the next inevitable price rise. Even if inflation cools off in the coming quarters, prices will be sticky. A range of things from housing to petrol and restaurant bills are unlikely to ever shrink back to their former levels.

A threshold has been crossed. We may well have seen the end of cheap and good in Singapore.

Besides the global drivers, there are also factors in Singapore itself, part of which may be attributed to a new vision of Singapore.

This is a vision of Singapore as a world-class, global “hub” city replete with iconic towers, IRs and F1 grands prix, populated by a new, swank class of rich residents. In this gleaming image, Singapore upgrades and value-adds our way upwards firmly into the developed world and its standard of living. We race up the economic ladder, going from barbers to hairstylists, production line operators to personal bankers, from sinsehs to pharmaceuticals.

We may well aspire to such a vision. But there is a price tag for our world-class ambitions: world level prices. After all, in global cities like London, New York and Hong Kong, hotel rates and some other costs are on par, or higher.

Our world-class ambitions go beyond economics to an inflation driven by spiralling expectations.

When we imagine Singapore the global city, we imagine ourselves as global citizens, living in an earthly paradise. Some here can afford to pass through those gates.

For some others, however, the emerging reality is a middle class purgatory. We work harder and harder for salaries which, while sizeable in absolute terms, prove insufficient to buy paradise here. We may be rich, but feel poor, like the Japanese have infamously felt for decades.



DAWN OF EXPENSIVE BUT BAD ERA?

Worse-off still are those who will have few or no skills to participate in the emerging economy. During Singapore’s baby boom years, only some 4-to-6 per cent went to university and many did not even go beyond primary school. Now in the late ‘40s to ‘50s, they may well struggle.

Yet, even if we are witnessing the end of cheap and good, this does not automatically mean that there will be expensive but quality products and services. Instead, it is more natural that as prices shift, questions arise about quality. Upgrading and rebranding can simply be recipes to get people to pay more for the same thing, and thus, too much for the mediocre. What is “good” at lower prices will seem “poor value” at a much higher price.

The end of cheap and good may usher in a period of expensive but bad.

I feel this many mornings when I drive on the CTE. We are promised a world-class transport system, as long as we pay a high price to buy cars and for road-use charges. We pay at all the gantries they have added, yet we still find ourselves in traffic snarls.

On Orchard Road, coffee may cost $7 but that does not mean it’s made well and served hot and with a smile. It’s easy to raise prices, and much harder to raise standards.

Even if we aspire to being a global city, transitions are tricky. Sometimes we lose something that we hold dear, like the ideal of cheap and good, before we even realise it. This is especially when, as with inflation now, quite unexpected external events combine with internal policies like GST hikes, and other price rises.

It is not clear what can be done now. It is not clear that the problem is fully recognised as something that can and should be tackled, rather than just endured as inevitable. Perhaps, we can console ourselves with three things in Singapore that are still cheap (even free) and good. Our clean air, public libraries and hawker centres. Perhaps, those are enough.

ASEAN’s Charter: Promises Vs Realities

ASEAN Ministers meeting in Singapore last week were pushed to address diverse controversies ranging from the Thai-Cambodian dispute over the Preah Vihar temple to the situation in Myanmar. Underlying these was an ongoing agenda on Asean institutions, including a promised human rights body and a Charter.


The Asean Charter is intended to articulate principles and objectives, give legal personality to the grouping, and shape its key processes and institutions.

All 10 governments had signed the document in Singapore at the end of 2007 and have given themselves one year to ratify.

This is not without controversy. Is the Asean Charter the right step forward for the grouping of these diverse neighbours toward becoming a community?

Proponents urge that all embrace the document, while opponents argue that it is not worth the effort. Differences found expression in a public debate between two heads of think tanks in Singaporean: Both of whom are ambassadors.

Mr Barry Desker, Director of the Rajaratnam School, believes Asean did less than it could have. It has even gone backwards in some areas.

Professor Tommy Koh, who chaired the High Level Task force that negotiated the Charter, defends it as a good and workable compromise.

Debate between Charter proponents and opponents will likely grow. Indonesia, Thailand and the Philippines have yet to ratify the Charter and being voluble democracies open to debate, will hold public and parliamentary discussions before deciding.

Words: no substitute for action

The debate might consider not just the words on paper. Unfolding events this past week hint at how the Charter might function. First, does the Charter do enough to deal with Myanmar or other states that might violate the norms of the group? Myanmar last week announced its ratification of the Charter. This may hearten Charter proponents as one more step forward.

But the junta has also announced that Ms Aung San Suu Kyi will be kept under house arrest until the end of next year. A time limit is good, but given that Asean urges bolder steps toward democracy — a free and fair election in 2010 and freedom for Ms Suu Kyi — this shows that the generals do what they want.

The junta’s ratification seems more a gesture than a genuine agreement to Asean’s values and norms in the Charter, which include democracy, human rights and good governance.

Instead, the generals claim to uphold the norm of non-intervention, another principle enshrined in the Charter.

So too went the debate about the Asean human rights body, a promise from Article 14 of the Charter. Optimists urged it forward, and the High Level Panel on its terms of reference met for the first time in Singapore.

Yet that first meeting revealed differences and a lack of ambition. While some called for monitoring and peer pressure, no one even set out the long-term goal of a more independent commission like those in the United Nations and some other regions.

To the contrary, some countries, including Myanmar, had invoked the principle of non-interference to argue even against reporting on human rights records. If this continues, the body and the Charter will be emaciated.

Some, like Mr Desker, urge that Myanmar’s membership be suspended, while Prof Koh argues that if Myanmar were not a member, further inroads could be put out of reach.

The hard truth is that the international community does not easily deal with any country that wilfully disregards norms. Note the six-party talks about North Korea at the sidelines in Singapore. Even with the United States, China, Japan and Russia on board, progress on the issue has been slow.

Can we reasonably expect Asean to do more with Myanmar than the UN or six parties have done with these other states, even if its Charter is more strongly worded? Words alone — whether in the infant Asean Charter or the long established UN Charter — are no substitute for political will, and firm and fair action.

Second, can the Charter ensure peace between neighbours? The Charter sets out principles for the peaceful settlement of disputes. Even Charter sceptics like Mr Desker admit “the risk of inter-state war in South-east Asia has declined today”, partly due to Asean.

Still, last week saw the Preah Vihar temple dispute between Cambodia and Thailand boiling over. Military forces had squared off and Cambodia has sought intercession by the UN and by Asean. Yet Asean suggests that bilateral consultation and negotiations continue.

The Preah Vihar incident suggests the present, relatively happy situation of peace cannot be taken for granted. If need be, the Charter can serve as a basis for mediation for the two sides to this or other crises, and engrave the habits of peace more deeply. It would also serve, if conflict eventuates, as a basis for rightly criticising both sides.

Three clues to Charter Efficacy

Can the Charter make Asean more efficient and effective? Three very different events from last week may shed some light.

First, at the Asean Regional Forum, the traditional night of fun and frivolous acts by visiting foreign ministers was jettisoned.

Second, the Asean Secretary-General Surin Pitsuwan also reported back on the efforts made in the aftermath of Cyclone Nargis.

Third, the Asean chairmanship has moved to Thailand, where the Samak government is facing domestic political pressures and had had its foreign minister resign under pressure just weeks before the Singapore meeting.

These three events point to the fact that Asean needs to be both more trim and also more institutionalised. Charter proponents like Prof Koh are right to note the Charter takes a good step forward by creating a coordinating council to try to ensure that the many meetings that Asean holds are trimmed to be more effective and directed.

It is also a step forward to empower the Asean Secretary-General to monitor and report non-compliance to the summit.

An Asean secretariat with more responsibility can hedge against depending too much on the Asean chair, especially when domestic politics heat up and distract.

Some Charter opponents like Mr Desker wish to make Asean more “people centred” by involving Parliaments. This is laudable but may inadvertently make Asean even more unwieldy. Democracy is, after all, still unsettled within most Asean member countries and to democratise at the regional level at the present time may make things worse.

Can the Charter make a difference? Cases like Myanmar, where there is so much recalcitrance and suspicion, will always be hard to handle.

Yet for the first time, the Charter would allow the Summit to take emergency measures and to deal with serious breaches by any member state. Even if there is no consensus, the Summit can decide under Article 20 on how to deal with a specific situation. To me, this implicitly opens the door to non-consensus decisions, if the leaders see fit. Additionally, there are many other improvements, some surveyed above, that can be taken, and on which the Charter can help.

Ratify, Review and Criticise

The Charter needs to be ratified. To do any less, after having signed off on it after a year of negotiations at their 40th anniversary summit, is to invite international ridicule of Asean.

Yet, even as ratification is necessary, it is far from sufficient. The Charter is not an end in itself, but just a useful beginning.

There is a five-year review built into the Charter and this should be used. Political-will needs to be built to go further and faster in future. The voices that call for a better Charter may not be so wrong in principle, but on the question of timing.

Hopefully, criticism will not engender resistance and cynicism, but inspire hope for further change and improvement.

TODAY Weekend 2-3 Aug 2008

Wednesday, July 16, 2008

It's Time for ASEAN To Deliver

ASEAN foreign ministers meet in Singapore shortly. The meeting will mark the end of Singapore's chairmanship of the group, to be followed by Thailand's. But domestic politics in Bangkok recently resulted in the resignation of Thai Foreign Minister Noppadon Pattama. Thailand will no doubt have a new foreign minister soon, but snap elections cannot be ruled out.

Such political problems are not isolated to Thailand. They seem endemic to the region. Political in-fighting in Thailand, Malaysia and the Philippines is a distraction and may test Asean's stability.

In addition, Indonesia is beginning a long and, in all likelihood, turbulent electioneering period. Financial turmoil in Vietnam and rising prices of oil, rice and other basics across the region are presenting complex and multiple challenges.

Concurrently with these domestic challenges, Asean has upped its regional ambitions. Following on the promise to build an Asean community, the grouping signed an Asean Charter and also a road map for economic integration. The charter, to be ratified by the end of this year, promises a more efficient Asean and also a specific human rights body.

In the aftermath of Cyclone Nargis in Myanmar, Asean took on an unprecedented role, attempting to coordinate relief and reconstruction and intercede between the junta and a critical international community.

Such ambitions are welcome. The main Asean economies have done relatively well this year, despite difficulties. The integration of a market of some 500 million people can help further growth. Alongside economic integration, cooperation must be strengthened in other areas as well. A united and credible Asean can help its own peoples and also be an accepted and effective hub in the wider Asian region.

But ambitions beget expectations and run the risk of disappointment. Clear deadlines, like those in the economic integration blueprint, mean that it would become obvious when promises are delayed or not met at all.

Asean has made progress in the last year. But it is not clear whether integration is moving fast enough, given the pace of global events and higher expectations.

It is true that after the Asean foreign ministers meet among themselves, they will welcome representatives from major powers like China, Japan and the United States in the Asean Regional Forum (ARF). The existence of such a forum shows that Asean is still credible.

But that forum exists in part because many are unsure as to who would lead the region. Despite recent improvements, there are still tensions and competition between China and Japan. There are also questions over the future role of the US.

Asean can serve as a hub not because the group is strong. Indeed, it is precisely because Asean is relatively weak and unthreatening that it is acceptable to all. Asean's hub status is something of a default position. The wider initiatives that Asean hosts, such as the ARF and East Asia Summit, are often criticised for showing only slow or no progress.

Asean cannot rest on its laurels. There are competing ideas and frameworks that are emerging. For instance, some are suggesting converting the six-party talks on North Korea's nuclear programmes into a permanent framework for East Asia - with the US, China and Japan in the lead, and without Asean's involvement.

Another recent proposal that may eclipse Asean's role has come from Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd. His proposal for an Asia-Pacific community would link the giants of the region, including the US. Unlike the ARF or the East Asian Summit, Asean would not play host.

There are questions about these and other proposed regional architectures. But they point nevertheless to recurring doubts about the continuing relevance of Asean.

This does not mean that Asean had been wrong to propose a charter, economic integration and a human rights body. Nor was it misplaced for Asean to be involved with the problems of Myanmar, both in the wake of Cyclone Nargis as well as in the country's human rights situation. On the contrary, such ambitions are necessary to make Asean more credible to its own citizens and relevant to the wider international community. But delivering on promises must now be key.

One litmus test will be ratifying the Asean Charter by the end of this year. Thailand, Indonesia and the Philippines are among those who have yet to ratify the charter. Each is a loud and complex democracy; ratification will involve much horse trading among its domestic constituencies.

Another sign will be progress on economic integration. With concerns over inflation and uncertainty about the regional and international economy, protectionist tendencies may surface in efforts to buffer domestic producers.

A third measure will be Asean's efforts in the wake of Cyclone Nargis. Even if the the junta's response has been wanting, Asean, having taken on the issue, must visibly expend every effort to make things better.

Our regional hopes rest on the domestic politics of Asean's member states being able to deliver results for the greater good of the group. Having made promises, Asean must deliver - and soon.

[INSET] SETTING THE RIGHT PACE

Asean has made progress in the last year. But it is not clear whether integration is moving fast enough, given the pace of global events and higher expectations.

The Straits Times, 16 July 2008

Monday, June 23, 2008

Stunning Copenhagen, or Sunny S’pore?


The best cities to live in are those with a diverse and vibrant outlook

COPENHAGEN basks in sunshine, all mid-summer revelry, with songs and lots of drinking. The city also celebrates being first among “The World’s 25 Top Cities for Quality of life”, a list compiled by Monocle, the magazine edited by trend-setter Tyler Brule, founder of design magazine Wallpaper.

Even a short visit shows the city’s strengths. Architecture, design and gourmet food combine with good public transportation and a bicycling culture that allows for easy, non-polluting transport. For recreation, there are green public spaces and trendy cafes, such as K Bar. On a warm day, you can jump into the harbour at Islands Brygge, a bathing spot in the middle of the city.

Monocle says: “There are many reasons why Copenhagen trumped the other cities ... seamless urban planning, paving the way for the mobility and, ultimately, the happiness of its residents.”

Copenhagen is not very big, with a population of about 2 million people and a compact centre that mixes cobblestone streets with new buildings in the famous, modern, Danish minimalist style. Like so many of the residents, I decided to get around by bicycle. Traffic here, unlike that in too many mega-cities, respects cyclists.

I zipped :safely from the sleek, modern Black diamond building along the waterfront to the famous old Tivoli gardens and castle, then on to designer furniture shops and art galleries. I visited the Christiani area, a colourful, graffiti-decorated “free town”, where people squat in old buildings without paying rent and sell hash pipes.

I looked out over the low city skyline, punctured by church spires and the giant turbines that harness the wind for power.

By the end of the morning, I had agreed: Copenhagen is a great city.

CLOSED SOCIETY AND MINDS

Yet, when I met Pia, a young Danish management consultant who has lived in Singapore, she says she wants to return. Why?

Singapore is the only city in Asia, outside Japan, to make the Monocle listings. But it is ranked at 22, slipping from 17 last year.

Pia told me that one thing Singapore has for her taste, is that it is in Asia. Our hinterland fascinates her — both the societies and the future possibilities for economic growth. In comparison, she finds Copenhagen a bit cut off, even from Europe.

Another factor she pointed to is that Danish society is relatively closed. A graduate of the Copenhagen School of Business, Pia thinks not more than 10 per cent of her class has gone abroad to work. Foreign professionals visit Copenhagen, but few stay. Her city, she says as we sit in a French-style cafe, is quite sophisticated and European, but not really cosmopolitan and global.

A Pakistani taxi driver I talked to made much the same point, from a very different standpoint. He had been here for more than 30 years. But he complained that, for years, there has been no mosque built in the country. This will change with plans to build a large Grand Mosque in the near future.

But still, he went on, most people do not understand Islam. To him, the notorious Danish cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed showed the gap in cross-cultural understanding.

The native Danish professional and the Pakistani emigre taxi driver lead me to a question about so-called “liveable” cities. What makes a city liveable? Who is it who lives there? And why?

A LITTLE DIRT AND DIVERSITY

Many cities lack the basics of clean air and water. In a world under stress from climate change, such environmental goods are becoming scarce resources. Many cities also lack well-planned and maintained infrastructure, or struggle to contain crime.

Yet, as Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew once remarked, those basics are not enough to make a great city. He called for life and vibrancy, colour and — metaphorically — a bit of dirt.

But colour, life and even dirt cannot be organised, or set up as easily as a wireless hot spot. And we should not think the liveliness of a city can be counted in terms of the number of designer bars and clubs.

Monocle, for example, sets one criteria that you can easily get a drink of beer after midnight. You can in Copenhagen — some bars stay open all night. But that may not mean much if you are a Pakistani Muslim in the city.

The life of a city cannot be measured by narrow indicators. And a city cannot be built only for the ultra-rich or the stylish jet-set. It should be liveable for the vast majority of those who live there and accommodate their diversity.

So, there can be stylish spots and boutiques but there should also be humble places, like Singapore’s hawker centres and public housing heartlands. The best cities should have places that buzz with fast-paced life, as well as green spaces in which to commune with nature.

There should be a sense of international style, as well as :unique and indigenous elements. There must be citizens and also those who have come from elsewhere, to inject something new.

The best cities are diverse — in economic standing, ethnicity, taste and outlook.

I reached the Kastrup airport, one of he best in Europe and the world, efficient and well-designed but relatively small. I had enjoyed visiting Copenhagen, but I looked forward to returning home.

- Published in TODAY, 23 June 2008

Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Human Rights: ASEAN’s Way Forward

THE Asean Charter, unveiled at last year’s Singapore Summit, surprised many by giving attention to human rights, enshrining these as a purpose and principle.

Article 14 of the Charter promises to create a human rights body for the group. Many welcomed this as a bold step, and even much-criticised Myanmar signed off on the Charter.

Another step forward will soon be taken. Next month, a high-level panel will be set up to agree on terms of reference for the new body.

But, despite the move towards democracy in some Asean countries, others doubt the region as a whole is ready to move ahead with human rights. And, as a recent workshop in Singapore for experts, non-governmental organisations and officials revealed, differences remain.

A first point of division is whether the Asean human rights body should comprise governmental officials or independent experts. If experts are appointed, they would have the independence to be more critical of violations. In contrast, government officials may play it safer rather than jeopardise friendly relations.

A second difference of opinion is whether it should have powers to investigate complaints in countries, like a regional police. Others propose that it only promote and monitor human rights.

A third controversy is whether all member countries should be on board, or if a minority who are willing may proceed more quickly.

Yet, while there are intra-Asean differences, there are areas of agreement that hold out the possibility of moving ahead together.

There are good reasons to do so. Consensus is the basic principle for the group. While the Charter does allow for an “Asean minus X” formula, this is expressly limited to economic agreements.

Maintaining Asean unity is key, especially on high-profile issues like human rights.

Yet, louder democracies in Asean, like Indonesia and the Philippines, may not wish to move only at the pace of the more cautious countries. Creative thinking is needed to find ways so that a foundation can be agreed for all, while allowing some to go further and faster.

Optional protocol agreements are one established method used by the international community for such purposes. This could be applied to differences of opinion about the powers for the Asean human rights body.

While the Asean Charter promises both promotion and protection for human rights, a variety of tools can be used. The international community already deploys a mixed tool kit, ranging from court-like proceedings and investigations by an international criminal court, to the use of force to prevent genocide and crimes against humanity.

But softer methods are also used, like monitoring, where a state reports on its human rights record, and opens itself to comments by others. Even today, the main method is still to “name and shame”.

Asean might proceed similarly with promotion and monitoring for all states, while some, using an optional protocol, could open themselves up to investigation if there are complaints.

The composition of the human rights body could also be balanced. Rather than one or the other, there could be a politically appointed panel of high officials, as well as an additional committee of experts.

Asean can also build a strong but limited foundation that all can agree on.

This is possible for women’s and children’s rights. All Asean countries have agreed to the relevant international treaties, albeit with some reservations.

Asean has also issued a strong declaration on the need to protect the rights of migrant workers. As Asean economies have become closely integrated, the movement of people across borders has grown. Moving ahead with transboundary issues that face migrants and women, like trafficking of women for sexual purposes, could help hundreds of thousands.

In comparison, to focus on individual cases that are within the domestic politics of any country can be of limited value and invoke many sensitivities.

The High-Level Panel to be established will have much important work to do. It should consult stakeholders broadly so that the process is perceived to be open and inclusive.

Human rights are no longer an alien concept, in contrast to the talk about “Asian values” so prevalent in the ’90s. Asean should set out a long-term vision for a regional human rights body of the highest standard.

But the roadmap to that vision may need to be travelled step-by-step so that all countries join in that journey. Asean should avoid the situation that some race ahead while others — perhaps Vietnam, Laos and Myanmar — stand still. Only if Asean proceeds with some fundamental baselines can human rights help unify the promised regional community.

Friday, November 16, 2007

ASEAN:Promises, Controversies and Benefits

By Simon SC Tay, TODAY, November 16 2007

LEADERS from the Association of South-east Asian Nations (Asean) leaders will soon gather in Singapore for their 13th Summit, which will also mark the grouping’s 40th anniversary. There are promises of an Asean Charter, controversies over Myanmar and of course, there will be the signature photo of leaders in a line, holding hands, to signify unity.

But what — beyond the pomp and ceremony and political declarations— can people expect? How, if at all, will Asean matter to people and to businesses?For too long, Asean has been a network for bureaucrats who carry on with their regular work, with neither clear benefits to ordinary people nor businesses in the region.

But there are welcome signs that this is changing.The Asean Charter, which has not been officially unveiled, will be a key document that sets the ground rules for the grouping. While its language will be formal and legal, we should hope that it captures the essence of Asean coming together as a community, with societies more deeply engaged with each other, even as their differences are respected.

Thus, it is important that the Charter should aspire to democracy, human rights and good governance as well as the promise to create a human rights body. If it can lay the path for progress in key areas such cross-border trafficking of women, sexual exploitation of children and protection of migrant workers, millions in Asean can be assured greater human dignity.

Another key document to be presented at the Summit will be the blueprint for an Asean Economic Community. This promises to set definite goals and deadlines for the major sectors of the 10 economies to integrate into one market.

This is key towards helping businesses buy, sell and do business seamlessly across Asean, and enable member nations to compete with China and India.

As markets integrate, there must be safeguards against unintended evils — like environmental harms, erosion of workers’rights and unsafe products.We should also pay attention to the poorer areas of Asean to help them develop infrastructure and educate their people with skills so they can benefit.

On the whole, economic integration can boost growth and help more people to rise above the poverty line.

The environment will be high on the Summit agenda — a rare but timely occurrence.Global attention about climate change has risen dramatically this year. This is a problem that not only affects the rich, it threatens devastating consequences on poor countries and the most vulnerable sectors with sea-level rise, droughts, floods and increasingly- extreme storms.

To protect current and future generations, Asean leaders should take steps to fully and jointly understand the potential impacts on the region. They should also begin to map out win-win areas, so they can make efforts that benefit them locally and also help slow climate change.

Increasing energy efficiency, stopping massive deforestation and addressing the haze from fires in Indonesia are some steps that might hopefully be considered.

The Asean Summit can and should also give attention to the problems in Myanmar. Asean is acting more decisively and credibly in response to the recent violence in that country. It can play a key role in egging regional giants like China, India and Japan on to support United Nations-led efforts.

Yet, while this work must be done, realistically, we cannot expect the Summit to make much immediate improvement to the lives of people in Myanmar.

More significant steps can be taken; but it will take a long journey to find solutions to Myanmar’s decades of travails.

Looking further ahead, there are many things that have to be done for people and businesses to understand Asean and see its benefits. The objective is not just to provide praise, but also fair and critical appraisals of Asean.

The Singapore Institute of International Affairs will undertake such an effort in the aftermath of the Asean summit to bring experts from Asean with others from other Asian countries and the United States.

Public education efforts should also be stepped up in every member country. Film, food and other popular means can be used to get more people interested in Asean.

A social and cultural agenda for understanding Asean should also accompany the economic integration and the political and security community in the region.

Some Asean members are witnessing periods of high growth and optimism, such as Vietnam. Others, while undergoing political contestation and change, like Thailand and Indonesia, have underlying strengths.

The conditions are right for Asean to show — 10 years after the Asian crisis — that they are rising to new challenges to create a competitive as well as caring community that deserves international credibility.

The leaders at the Summit must lead this effort with progress towards a common vision of the community and to accept binding rules that peacefully deal with deadlocks and keep the region moving forward together.

Monday, August 6, 2007

Real Steps, Not Rhetoric

By Simon SC Tay, TODAY, August 6 2007

ASEAN Foreign Ministers in Manila this week surprised many by agreeing on a human rights commission, after initially strong objections by Myanmar.

While this will delight human rights supporters, the Association of South-east Asian Nations may yet frustrate hopes and expectations. For while there is agreement to put a mechanism for human rights into the charter being drafted for the grouping, there is no consensus on the commission’s scope, how it will operate or even when it will start.

Hopes will run high, especially among those non-governmental organisations that have been pushing for an Asean human rights mechanism — Asean governments had raised the possibility of creating one back in 1993.

Cynics may, however, suggest that Asean’s current move is more about perception. It is likely that habits of consultationwill continue, and states remain cautious about clashing over matters solely within another’s sovereign territory.

What can be expected? How can Asean move forward, avoiding cynicism on one hand and over-ambition on the other?

The context for this new initiative is important. The grouping aims to be a community with economic, security and sociocultural pillars by 2015. To be a community, mutual understanding needs to be fostered, including on the rights of individuals — not just between governments, but also the peoples of the region. While there are universal norms of human rights, differences in the levels of economic development, religion and other characteristics can make understanding and practices vary from one society to another.

Secondly, human rights commissions and mechanisms do differ from each other. Europe has the most advanced mechanism. Citizens from one country are allowed to complain and bring cases against any country before a regional court on the full gamut of human rights.

The decisions of that regional court can override the national courts and change national laws and practices. This process that allows individuals to complain is a legal revolution in rights for Europeans emerging in parallel with the creation of a European Union.

Without a similar commitment to a political union in the immediate future, Asean cannot realistically emulate Europe. It would be like comparing apples to durians.

Asean should understand the European experience without idolising or aping it. After all, other regional human rights mechanisms exist in the Americas and Africa but work in more limited ways. In many cases, rather than emphasising court-like procedures, the systems give ample room for political negotiation and compromise.

Human rights mechanisms grow over time. At the United Nations, for example, the past decade has seen such mechanisms strengthened with the creation of a human rights commissioner and the revamp of its council. Separate tribunals have also been set up to handle specific situations such as the former Yugoslavia. While far from perfect, these have been improvements.

Asean may, similarly, begin its human rights initiative more modestly, while holding out the possibility of stronger mechanisms in the future. Where can Asean best begin?

Public education is a necessary foundation. In rural districts in some Asean member states, the understanding of human rights may be rudimentary or even non-existent. In some Asean capitals too, human rights continue to be controversial and seen as an alien, “Western” concept. Sentiments still echo from the 1990s, when spokesmen from Singapore, Malaysia and other states spoke about “Asian values” that differed from the West.

Public education on human rights in Asean can, and should, reframe that debate. Asean’s peoples need to understand human rights and see them as being part of their own heritage and beliefs, rather than a Western imposition.

But what about taking action? A key challenge is deciding where to begin. Some will point to the problems in Myanmar. Others may emphasise issues of media freedom or the need to protect racial and religious minorities.

Perhaps one way to prioritise is to look at existing areas of agreement among Asean member states. While there are many international human rights treaties and conventions, only two have near-universal acceptance in the region.

These two conventions are on the rights of children and the elimination of discrimination against women. Asean can usefully begin by targeting the illegal traffic in women and children. More broadly, improving the rights of Asean children to education, shelter and food can help ensure the basic rights or the region’s future generation.

Another priority would seem to be where the human rights issue is not wholly within one country but has a transboundary element. Foreign workers are an example. The large flows of workers between Asean member states is likely to increase as we move towards closer economic integration.

Yet, tensions over their treatment surface regularly. In Malaysia, for example, thousands of undocumented Indonesian workers are being held by the authorities. Intra-Asean cooperation can help ensure the fair treatment of foreign workers. Frictions and fears about working abroad can be eased, and this would help economic integration.

What, then, will Asean do about human rights in Myanmar? Political sensitivities and security dimensions still exist. Ties with China, India and other major powers must also enter into the equation for any solution.

Pressing for change by Asean is needed but that is best left to political judgement by leaders and foreign ministers.

An Asean human rights commission may, however, assist by providing timely information and assessment on the human rights situation in that country.

In keeping with so much in Asean, the key to moving ahead with a human rights mechanism is to take first steps in a timely manner. But it is also important that the steps be real ones, not rhetoric or empty promises. It would also help if the steps were to be aligned with the overall ambitions of being a community. The journey ahead will be long but Asean is heading in the right direction.