Friday, November 16, 2007

ASEAN:Promises, Controversies and Benefits

By Simon SC Tay, TODAY, November 16 2007

LEADERS from the Association of South-east Asian Nations (Asean) leaders will soon gather in Singapore for their 13th Summit, which will also mark the grouping’s 40th anniversary. There are promises of an Asean Charter, controversies over Myanmar and of course, there will be the signature photo of leaders in a line, holding hands, to signify unity.

But what — beyond the pomp and ceremony and political declarations— can people expect? How, if at all, will Asean matter to people and to businesses?For too long, Asean has been a network for bureaucrats who carry on with their regular work, with neither clear benefits to ordinary people nor businesses in the region.

But there are welcome signs that this is changing.The Asean Charter, which has not been officially unveiled, will be a key document that sets the ground rules for the grouping. While its language will be formal and legal, we should hope that it captures the essence of Asean coming together as a community, with societies more deeply engaged with each other, even as their differences are respected.

Thus, it is important that the Charter should aspire to democracy, human rights and good governance as well as the promise to create a human rights body. If it can lay the path for progress in key areas such cross-border trafficking of women, sexual exploitation of children and protection of migrant workers, millions in Asean can be assured greater human dignity.

Another key document to be presented at the Summit will be the blueprint for an Asean Economic Community. This promises to set definite goals and deadlines for the major sectors of the 10 economies to integrate into one market.

This is key towards helping businesses buy, sell and do business seamlessly across Asean, and enable member nations to compete with China and India.

As markets integrate, there must be safeguards against unintended evils — like environmental harms, erosion of workers’rights and unsafe products.We should also pay attention to the poorer areas of Asean to help them develop infrastructure and educate their people with skills so they can benefit.

On the whole, economic integration can boost growth and help more people to rise above the poverty line.

The environment will be high on the Summit agenda — a rare but timely occurrence.Global attention about climate change has risen dramatically this year. This is a problem that not only affects the rich, it threatens devastating consequences on poor countries and the most vulnerable sectors with sea-level rise, droughts, floods and increasingly- extreme storms.

To protect current and future generations, Asean leaders should take steps to fully and jointly understand the potential impacts on the region. They should also begin to map out win-win areas, so they can make efforts that benefit them locally and also help slow climate change.

Increasing energy efficiency, stopping massive deforestation and addressing the haze from fires in Indonesia are some steps that might hopefully be considered.

The Asean Summit can and should also give attention to the problems in Myanmar. Asean is acting more decisively and credibly in response to the recent violence in that country. It can play a key role in egging regional giants like China, India and Japan on to support United Nations-led efforts.

Yet, while this work must be done, realistically, we cannot expect the Summit to make much immediate improvement to the lives of people in Myanmar.

More significant steps can be taken; but it will take a long journey to find solutions to Myanmar’s decades of travails.

Looking further ahead, there are many things that have to be done for people and businesses to understand Asean and see its benefits. The objective is not just to provide praise, but also fair and critical appraisals of Asean.

The Singapore Institute of International Affairs will undertake such an effort in the aftermath of the Asean summit to bring experts from Asean with others from other Asian countries and the United States.

Public education efforts should also be stepped up in every member country. Film, food and other popular means can be used to get more people interested in Asean.

A social and cultural agenda for understanding Asean should also accompany the economic integration and the political and security community in the region.

Some Asean members are witnessing periods of high growth and optimism, such as Vietnam. Others, while undergoing political contestation and change, like Thailand and Indonesia, have underlying strengths.

The conditions are right for Asean to show — 10 years after the Asian crisis — that they are rising to new challenges to create a competitive as well as caring community that deserves international credibility.

The leaders at the Summit must lead this effort with progress towards a common vision of the community and to accept binding rules that peacefully deal with deadlocks and keep the region moving forward together.

Monday, August 6, 2007

Real Steps, Not Rhetoric

By Simon SC Tay, TODAY, August 6 2007

ASEAN Foreign Ministers in Manila this week surprised many by agreeing on a human rights commission, after initially strong objections by Myanmar.

While this will delight human rights supporters, the Association of South-east Asian Nations may yet frustrate hopes and expectations. For while there is agreement to put a mechanism for human rights into the charter being drafted for the grouping, there is no consensus on the commission’s scope, how it will operate or even when it will start.

Hopes will run high, especially among those non-governmental organisations that have been pushing for an Asean human rights mechanism — Asean governments had raised the possibility of creating one back in 1993.

Cynics may, however, suggest that Asean’s current move is more about perception. It is likely that habits of consultationwill continue, and states remain cautious about clashing over matters solely within another’s sovereign territory.

What can be expected? How can Asean move forward, avoiding cynicism on one hand and over-ambition on the other?

The context for this new initiative is important. The grouping aims to be a community with economic, security and sociocultural pillars by 2015. To be a community, mutual understanding needs to be fostered, including on the rights of individuals — not just between governments, but also the peoples of the region. While there are universal norms of human rights, differences in the levels of economic development, religion and other characteristics can make understanding and practices vary from one society to another.

Secondly, human rights commissions and mechanisms do differ from each other. Europe has the most advanced mechanism. Citizens from one country are allowed to complain and bring cases against any country before a regional court on the full gamut of human rights.

The decisions of that regional court can override the national courts and change national laws and practices. This process that allows individuals to complain is a legal revolution in rights for Europeans emerging in parallel with the creation of a European Union.

Without a similar commitment to a political union in the immediate future, Asean cannot realistically emulate Europe. It would be like comparing apples to durians.

Asean should understand the European experience without idolising or aping it. After all, other regional human rights mechanisms exist in the Americas and Africa but work in more limited ways. In many cases, rather than emphasising court-like procedures, the systems give ample room for political negotiation and compromise.

Human rights mechanisms grow over time. At the United Nations, for example, the past decade has seen such mechanisms strengthened with the creation of a human rights commissioner and the revamp of its council. Separate tribunals have also been set up to handle specific situations such as the former Yugoslavia. While far from perfect, these have been improvements.

Asean may, similarly, begin its human rights initiative more modestly, while holding out the possibility of stronger mechanisms in the future. Where can Asean best begin?

Public education is a necessary foundation. In rural districts in some Asean member states, the understanding of human rights may be rudimentary or even non-existent. In some Asean capitals too, human rights continue to be controversial and seen as an alien, “Western” concept. Sentiments still echo from the 1990s, when spokesmen from Singapore, Malaysia and other states spoke about “Asian values” that differed from the West.

Public education on human rights in Asean can, and should, reframe that debate. Asean’s peoples need to understand human rights and see them as being part of their own heritage and beliefs, rather than a Western imposition.

But what about taking action? A key challenge is deciding where to begin. Some will point to the problems in Myanmar. Others may emphasise issues of media freedom or the need to protect racial and religious minorities.

Perhaps one way to prioritise is to look at existing areas of agreement among Asean member states. While there are many international human rights treaties and conventions, only two have near-universal acceptance in the region.

These two conventions are on the rights of children and the elimination of discrimination against women. Asean can usefully begin by targeting the illegal traffic in women and children. More broadly, improving the rights of Asean children to education, shelter and food can help ensure the basic rights or the region’s future generation.

Another priority would seem to be where the human rights issue is not wholly within one country but has a transboundary element. Foreign workers are an example. The large flows of workers between Asean member states is likely to increase as we move towards closer economic integration.

Yet, tensions over their treatment surface regularly. In Malaysia, for example, thousands of undocumented Indonesian workers are being held by the authorities. Intra-Asean cooperation can help ensure the fair treatment of foreign workers. Frictions and fears about working abroad can be eased, and this would help economic integration.

What, then, will Asean do about human rights in Myanmar? Political sensitivities and security dimensions still exist. Ties with China, India and other major powers must also enter into the equation for any solution.

Pressing for change by Asean is needed but that is best left to political judgement by leaders and foreign ministers.

An Asean human rights commission may, however, assist by providing timely information and assessment on the human rights situation in that country.

In keeping with so much in Asean, the key to moving ahead with a human rights mechanism is to take first steps in a timely manner. But it is also important that the steps be real ones, not rhetoric or empty promises. It would also help if the steps were to be aligned with the overall ambitions of being a community. The journey ahead will be long but Asean is heading in the right direction.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Back to the Burning Issue

By Simon SC Tay, TODAY, May 17 2007

DARK clouds are gathering as the dry season begins in Indonesia. Prospects increase that fires and haze will again return to plague the region later this year. This alarming prediction is the consensus among experts, non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and officials that emerged at a recent workshop in Jakarta.

This likely recurrence of the fires and haze is disconcerting. The problem has persisted for more than a decade and Asean's Agreement on the Transboundary is now in force. Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has apologised and promised action to address the problem.

While the dry season is a natural factor, analysts agree that human action, corporations and government policy in land clearing are factors that can be controlled.

Does the predicted haze mean nothing has been done? Does Indonesia still lack the political will to deal with the problem? Are there potential solutions ahead? Conflicting signals emerged from the workshop, organised by the Singapore Institute of International Affairs with two Indonesian partners - the Center for Strategic and International Studies, and the World Wide Fund (WWF) Indonesia.

Some sectors in Indonesia have signalled that the government will not ratify the Haze Agreement. At the workshop, the Indonesian Minister of Forestry asked for regional assistance on illegal logging in consideration for supporting the Haze Agreement. Some Indonesian Members of Parliament wish to make it a precondition that Singapore and Malaysia help not only on illegal logging, but also in other areas such as anti-corruption and extradition, for which a treaty has now been concluded with Singapore.

While these claims have been loudest, the recent workshop notably gave space to other voices from Indonesia. All the NGOs present, including the Indonesia Forum for the Environment, or Walhi, and WWF- Indonesia wish to address the haze issue.

Similarly, local and provincial officials working in the fire-prone regions of Riau and Kalimantan detailed their efforts to prevent the fires, and to put them out speedily if they start. Taking a similar view, officials from the Indonesian Ministry for the Environment gave their assurance at the workshop that Indonesia would do its best under its national plan to deliver on President Susilo's promise, with or without the Agreement.

These views among NGOs, local officials and the Ministry for the Environment give some cause for optimism about efforts to address the fires and haze - in contrast to the statements by the Minister for Forestry and some MPs.

There is increasing recognition that the fire and haze primarily affect Indonesia, and are therefore issues the country must address for its own good and for the good of its citizens. The effects on neighbouring states are, in this perspective, important but secondary.

The negative impacts of the fires and haze on Indonesia's public health and economy are well documented and costs are estimated to run into billions of dollars. But even more than these estimates, the attitude of the NGOs and local officials is based on their real-life experiences, close to the ground.

These NGOs have projects in fire-prone areas and work directly with the victims of the fires and the thickest haze. Similarly, local officials in these fire-prone areas see the catastrophe up close.

In contrast, some policy-makers who sit in Jakarta know little or nothing of the haze as a first-hand problem.

One area of contention remains the identity of the primary culprits. Indonesian NGOs allege that the fires and haze stem mainly from lands owned by some of the large plantation companies. Others - including some officials and corporate spokesmen - put the blame on the smaller-scale, traditional farmers.

There are also differences in opinion on what can be done to address the issue. It is possible that with the push from local officials, NGOs, and the Environment Ministry, momentum can gather for Indonesia to redouble its efforts and also ratify the Haze Agreement. But even supporters of the Agreement acknowledge that while it is an important marker and useful mechanism, it is no panacea.

Regional support will be needed. Singapore, Malaysia and other neighbours have agreed, under the Asean agreement, to put seed money into the Haze Control Fund. The presence of Singaporean and Malaysian NGOs at the workshop alongside their Indonesian counterparts showed the support for such cooperation, at a people-to-people level. Hopefully, governments will follow suit to increase cooperation. This seed of cooperation and support must be grown, as Indonesia would need more resources as it starts to put its anti-haze plans into action.

More ways forward were identified at the workshop. One of them will be efforts to retain and replant forests and the conservation of peatlands, which are the worst producers of haze. Such projects would address not just the regional haze but also climate-change concerns at the global level. An opportunity to link with climate change will arise with Indonesia hosting the conference of parties meeting of the Kyoto Protocol at the end of the year.

Efforts to encourage Indonesia to address the haze must continue, and new initiatives must be explored and pursued, even as we should brace ourselves for another season of burnt earth and grey skies.

Simon Tay is chairman of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs, a non-government think-tank.